Tim Tebow Or Cam Newton Who Would You Rather Build Around?

[GoSteelers15]

(01-10-2012 07:03 AM)Run Like Hell Wrote:  This is difficult because there's a lot to like about Tebow. His insane ability to be at the heart of a large surge by the Broncos and how often they pull it off would have me at this point leaning toward him, but if Cam Newton continues on a linear projection of improvement from his rookie season then he'll be a superstar.

That's what I'm saying Tebow has won but it almost seemed surreal and lucky. Cam is good and in a few years he will be Great!!!!

[neogeoz]

(03-08-2012 08:25 PM)jblythe4 Wrote:  Tim Tebow all the way. Tebow at least appears to want to keep working and get better. The both have natural talent, Cam more than Tebow, but Cam already thinks he is good, Tebow is a little more humble. Now granted they are both scrambling QB's, very Micheal Vickish, and look how well he's doing (sarcasm).

Where is Tebow's natural talent? He is a Fullback playing QB basically. His accuracy is terrible and he has no arm strength. They expect him to run or hand it off every play, so really his accuracy should be much higher considering they aren't even playing him for the pass most of the time.

[Clutchthese]

(03-11-2012 06:50 PM)neogeoz Wrote:  

(03-08-2012 08:25 PM)jblythe4 Wrote:  Tim Tebow all the way. Tebow at least appears to want to keep working and get better. The both have natural talent, Cam more than Tebow, but Cam already thinks he is good, Tebow is a little more humble. Now granted they are both scrambling QB's, very Micheal Vickish, and look how well he's doing (sarcasm).

Where is Tebow's natural talent? He is a Fullback playing QB basically. His accuracy is terrible and he has no arm strength. They expect him to run or hand it off every play, so really his accuracy should be much higher considering they aren't even playing him for the pass most of the time.

Truth... he speaks the truth.

Look at Tebows passer rating... it's CRAP! Cam Newton broke passing records AND rushing records. Cam Newton wins this category hands down.

[wils172]

I can't believe this is a serious debate. The answer is far and away Cam Newton. He's more athletic than tebow as a runner and a MUCH better passer. No arguement in my mind.

[rcturbos]

(03-12-2012 07:43 PM)wils172 Wrote:  I can't believe this is a serious debate. The answer is far and away Cam Newton. He's more athletic than tebow as a runner and a MUCH better passer. No arguement in my mind.

I agree with you but here is my go on it:

Both have great talent dont get me wrong.. But I think that Tebow has a little bit better talent so I think that I rather built it around Tm Tebow..

[nikon12]

Newton has the ability to throw the ball, and would call him a better runner as well. Yes Tebow is a good person and leader, but he is no Newton.

[Joe Robinson]

I know that Tebowmania has many people excited; but the hype just doesn't cover up the fact that he is not that great of a Quarterback. How anyone would not choose Cam Newton over him is beyond me. Tebow will end up being a backup at best in my mind. Newton will be a Pro Bowl QB.

[save27]

Tim Tebow could become really great in the upcoming years. But if I had to choose right now I would say Cam.

[Joe Robinson]

(03-16-2012 08:19 PM)save27 Wrote:  Tim Tebow could become really great in the upcoming years. But if I had to choose right now I would say Cam.

You're right. He could become a great H-Back. A great QB? I wouldn't count on it. His accuracy is horrifying at best.